AI visibility
Google AI Overviews and AI Mode: what they do to your traffic and what to do
Google now answers many searches with AI-generated text. What Google AI Overviews and AI Mode are, which pages lose clicks, which keep them and how to check the effect in Search Console.
What Google AI Overviews and AI Mode are
The marketing lead at an accountancy practice in Leicester opens Search Console. The blog appears in Google more than ever and gets fewer visits, because above its article on VAT returns, which still ranks first, Google now shows a summary that already answers the question. This is the most common effect of Google AI Overviews. A page keeps its ranking and loses clicks, mainly on searches that can be answered in a few lines.
Google AI Overviews are the AI-generated summaries that appear above the results for some searches. They answer in a few lines and include links to the pages the information comes from. AI Mode is a conversational way of searching inside Google, where the written answer fills the screen and the user can keep asking follow-ups.
Both rely on Google's index. To appear as a source, a page must be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet in the regular results. Google says no special optimisation is needed beyond good SEO practice. Availability varies by country, language and type of search, and the design changes often.
Why Google AI Overviews reduce clicks on some searches
When the answer sits at the top, some users already have what they came for. If someone asks how many days' holiday they are entitled to, or what a VAT return is, a short summary is enough. The page that used to get that click may still be cited as a source and yet receive fewer visits.
The shift does not always show in rankings. Your page can remain the first organic result while sitting further down the screen. In Search Console it usually looks like stable or rising impressions with a falling click-through rate. Click-through rate, or CTR, is the share of people who click after seeing your result.
Fewer informational clicks do not necessarily mean fewer customers. Many of those visits never led to a purchase or a quote request. So the figure that settles the question is conversions, meaning the call, form or sale that comes from each page.
The three-line test: which pages lose clicks and which do not
Take the pages that used to get the most visits from Google and, for each one, write the answer to its main question in three lines. If it fits, the page is exposed. If it does not, a summary can only point the way and the user has a reason to click. The test sorts your pages into five types.
Closed answer
Definitions, deadlines, figures or simple steps, such as what a VAT return is. They fit in three lines and are the most exposed. Decide whether to enrich the page, merge it into a fuller one or accept that its role is now to be a cited source.
Decision with nuance
Choosing between a limited company and staying a sole trader, or between renting and buying premises, depends on the case. The summary gives a pointer and the reader then looks for someone who understands their situation. Strengthen these pages with cases and criteria.
Search to buy or hire
Someone searching "kitchen refit quote Bristol" or "trail running shoes size 10" wants to act. They need prices, photos, stock or a form, and all of that lives on your site. Protect these pages, because they are usually the ones that convert.
Brand or local search
People who type your name or search "employment solicitor near me" want to reach a specific place. Your Google Business Profile, your reviews and a clear website with address and opening hours decide the outcome.
Tool or resource
Calculators, simulators, templates or downloadable spec sheets. The user has to visit the page to use them, so a summary takes little away.
How to measure the impact of AI Overviews in Search Console
Search Console does not always let you isolate visits that come from these formats. The most reliable method is to compare groups of queries over time.
- 01
Export 16 months of queries
In the Performance report, export the queries for the last 16 months, the most the tool keeps. Save the file as your baseline.
- 02
Sort them into four groups
Informational questions, brand searches, commercial searches and local searches. The regular expression filter, a small language for matching text patterns, helps group the queries that start with "what", "how" or "why".
- 03
Compare with the previous year
Compare each group with the same period a year earlier to allow for seasonality. Look at clicks, impressions, CTR and average position. If a group holds its impressions and position but loses CTR, the summary is probably resolving those searches.
- 04
Drill down to page level
Find the URLs that have lost the most clicks and search their main queries on Google yourself. Check whether a summary appears and whether your page is among the sources. Then check whether its answer fits in three lines.
- 05
Cross-check with conversions
In your analytics, link calls, forms or sales to landing pages. You will then know whether the drop affects the business or only the reading. Repeat the comparison every quarter with the same groups.
Example
A Leicester accountancy blog, page by page
Back to the practice from the opening, a typical case with six staff and a blog of about forty articles on tax and self-employment admin. The marketing lead sorts the queries into groups. Informational questions hold their impressions and lose CTR, while brand and local searches stay steady.
Then she goes through the pages one by one. Articles on what a form is or when a deadline falls fit in three lines. Others, such as when it makes sense to move from sole trader to limited company, do not. When she cross-checks with the contact forms, she sees that most quote requests come from those longer articles and from the services page.
That settles it. She merges several deadline articles into one tax calendar, updated every quarter, which the team also sends to clients. She extends the decision articles with a typical case explained step by step and signed by one of the accountants. And she stops judging the blog by total visits.
To follow it up, she compares the four query groups every quarter and counts quote requests by landing page. The practice accepts the loss of informational clicks as long as the pages that bring in clients keep doing so.
Common mistakes when reacting to AI Overviews
These are the most common reactions to falling clicks, and most of them cost time or visibility.
Blocking snippets
The nosnippet or max-snippet directives stop Google using your text in summaries, and they also cut back how your page appears in the regular results. For a small business that is usually a net loss.
Rewriting the whole site
Only some pages are exposed. Find the exposed ones first, then work only on those that lose clicks and also used to bring in customers.
Comparing month on month
Searches are seasonal. Compare August with July and you will mistake the summer slowdown for a change at Google.
Writing only for the summary
Trimming pages down to a two-line answer makes them quotable and leaves the reader no reason to click. Put the answer at the top and the depth underneath.
Watching clicks alone
Visits alone do not tell you whether a page works. Count its enquiries too. If they hold while visits fall, the page is still doing its job.
Two hours with Search Console, and where Obinova fits
Export your queries, sort them into the four groups and run the three-line test on your ten most-visited pages. You will come away with a short list of pages to enrich, merge or leave as they are.
Obinova is an AI agency based in Barcelona and Paris. Our AI marketing audit reviews, among other things, how visible your brand is in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. This guide gives you a method to review the impact with your team or your web agency.
If these changes lead you to rethink how you produce content or win customers, our AI audit and consulting is the place to start. We map those processes with the people who run them and find where AI saves time. Repetitive tasks, such as gathering Search Console data into a spreadsheet every week, can be automated with n8n.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between AI Overviews and AI Mode?
AI Overviews are summaries that appear above the regular results for some searches. AI Mode is a conversational way of searching where the generated answer takes centre stage and the user can ask follow-up questions. Both cite pages with links and both rely on Google's index, so good SEO practice serves both.
How much traffic do Google AI Overviews take away?
There is no single figure that applies to every website. It depends on how much of your traffic comes from informational questions with short answers, which are the most exposed. A shop that lives on product searches will notice less than a blog of definitions. To find out for your site, compare your query groups year on year in Search Console.
How do I get my pages into Google AI Overviews?
Google says there are no additional requirements. The page must be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet in the regular results. Beyond that, the usual practices apply: useful and reliable content, clear answers at the start of each section, good structure and a technically sound website. No technique guarantees that you will be cited as a source.
Can I stop Google using my content in AI Overviews?
Google says its AI features follow the same directives that control snippets, such as nosnippet, data-nosnippet and max-snippet. The drawback is that these directives also limit how your page appears in the regular results. For most small businesses, blocking content reduces visibility with no clear benefit.
Why do I have more impressions but fewer clicks in Search Console?
It is a common pattern when a generated answer resolves the search on Google's own page. Your page is still shown, sometimes as a source for the summary, but the user no longer needs to visit. Check by query group whether the change is concentrated on informational questions. If your conversions hold steady, the impact on the business is smaller.
Is it still worth writing blog articles?
Yes, as long as each article offers something a summary cannot, such as a case explained in detail, data from your own work, a template or a professional's judgement. Articles that only define a term lose value as a source of visits. Before writing, try answering the question in three lines. If it fits, the article needs more than a definition.