Automation
n8n vs Make, and where Zapier fits: which automation tool to choose
A fair comparison of n8n vs Make, with Zapier as the third of the best-known automation tools. It includes a method to estimate the real cost at your volume and four questions to decide. Obinova builds with n8n, and we say so upfront.
n8n vs Make and Zapier: what they share and where they differ
An online shop in Leicester runs five Zapier automations that work, but the bill rises every month and its operations manager wants to connect the warehouse software, which has no connector. She has heard about n8n and Make. For her, as for most small businesses, the choice between n8n vs Make, or staying on Zapier, turns less on features than on who will maintain the workflows, what shape they are and where the data has to stay.
At heart, all three follow the same logic. A trigger, such as a new email or an order, starts a series of steps that read, reshape and send data between apps. All three also let you add language models to sort, summarise or draft.
Zapier is a cloud platform designed so anyone can build step-by-step automations, called Zaps. Make is another cloud platform, with a canvas where each scenario is drawn as a chain of modules. n8n is a node editor that runs in its own cloud or on your server, and accepts code when needed.
Obinova builds its clients' automations with n8n. We have tried to keep this comparison fair, and in several cases we recommend a different tool. Features and pricing for all three change often, so check them on the official websites before you decide.
n8n, Make and Zapier compared on six criteria
Six criteria that usually decide the choice for a small business.
Ease of use
Zapier is the simplest. You pick an app, an event and an action, and the tool guides each step. Make asks you to understand how data flows between modules, though the canvas helps. n8n offers more options on each node, so it takes longer to learn without a technical background.
Logic and code
n8n lets you write JavaScript or Python at any point and build complex loops and conditions. Make handles branches and data transformations well with built-in functions. Zapier also supports code steps and branching, but shines on simple sequences.
AI and agents
All three integrate language models and have added agent features, meaning workflows where the model decides which tool to use. In n8n you choose the model, the tools and the exact point where a person approves. In Make and Zapier, AI is more guided and quicker to set up.
Where the data lives
Make and Zapier run in each vendor's cloud. n8n can be installed on a server owned by your company or a provider you choose. That matters when some data must not leave your infrastructure, in exchange for handling maintenance and backups.
Pricing model
Broadly, Zapier bills by tasks, which are the actions performed. Make bills by the operations or credits its modules use. n8n cloud counts executions of a whole workflow, however many steps it has. Self-hosted n8n is paid for in infrastructure and hours, within its licence terms.
Connectors
Zapier has the widest catalogue, Make is close behind and n8n has fewer native connectors. All three can call an app's API through HTTP requests when there is no connector, which takes a little more technical knowledge.
How to work out the real cost of n8n, Make or Zapier at your volume
Pricing pages cannot be compared directly, because each tool counts something different. This method gets you a reasonable estimate in an afternoon.
- 01
Map your workflows
List the automations you have or want. For each one, note the trigger and how many actions follow it.
- 02
Count monthly runs
How many orders, emails or forms start each workflow in a normal month, and in your busiest month. Use figures from your CRM or shop, not a guess.
- 03
Translate into each model
For example, a workflow with six actions that runs 300 times a month uses around 1,800 units in a model that counts every step, and 300 in a model that counts executions. The gap barely shows on two- or three-step workflows and widens quickly on long, frequent ones.
- 04
Add the costs the price list leaves out
The server and its upkeep if you self-host n8n, AI model usage, and the hours of whoever builds and maintains the workflows. Those hours often outweigh the subscription.
Four questions to choose between n8n, Make and Zapier
Answer them in this order. The first one settles a lot before you look at features.
Who will maintain the workflows?
If it is a business user with no technical training, Zapier or Make will make them independent sooner. If someone is comfortable with ideas like APIs or JSON, the text format apps use to exchange data, or you have a provider who documents well, n8n gives more.
Where must the data stay?
If you handle health data, legal case files or information your internal policy keeps in-house, the option to install n8n on your own server can be decisive.
What shape are your workflows?
Short and linear suits Zapier. Several branches and transformations suit Make. Long, frequent, or with AI agents and human approvals, n8n.
Do you need a new tool at all?
If the process changes every week, or your CRM already has the rule you need, perhaps none of the three. Settle the process first and check what your current tools can do.
Example
A Leicester cosmetics shop splits its workflows between Zapier and n8n
Back to the Leicester shop, an illustrative case. It has five Zaps. Four are short, such as alerting the team to each order or saving newsletter sign-ups to a sheet. The fifth is long. Each order creates the invoice, updates stock, alerts the warehouse and schedules a review request a week later.
The manager runs the cost method. The four short workflows use very little and she maintains them herself. The long one accounts for most of the usage and also needs to connect the warehouse software, which only offers an API. The four questions point in two different directions.
So the decision is mixed. The short workflows stay in Zapier. The long one is rebuilt in n8n, documented and run alongside the old Zap for a few weeks before the Zap is switched off. That way she can check that no order is lost.
To measure the change, she compares the monthly tool bill before and after, counts the stock errors the warehouse spots and logs the hours she spends on maintenance. If the n8n workflow takes more of her time than planned, she reviews it with whoever built it.
Common mistakes when comparing automation tools
Comparing entry prices only
Each tool's cheapest plan tells you little. What counts is the cost at your real volume, with your longest workflows.
Choosing by feature list
A tool with more options is no use if nobody in the company can maintain it. Before comparing options, think about who will open the editor when something breaks.
Forgetting the cost of switching
Workflows do not export from one tool to another. Migrating means rebuilding and retesting them, and those hours belong in the price comparison.
Migrating workflows that work
If your Zaps or Make scenarios do their job at a reasonable cost, leave them. Move only what is causing problems today.
Why Obinova builds with n8n, and when we will suggest another tool
We chose n8n because it lets us build workflows and AI agents precisely, install it on the client's infrastructure when the data requires it and document every step so your team can understand and improve it.
That does not make n8n the best option for everyone. If we see in the first meeting that a Zap or a CRM rule solves the problem, we will tell you.
To start, list your workflows with their steps and monthly runs, and note who maintains them today. With that sheet, the decision usually becomes clear within half an hour. If you choose n8n, our automation service designs the workflows with your teams and documents them. The quote comes after the first meeting.
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheapest: n8n, Make or Zapier?
It depends on your volume and the shape of your workflows. Each tool measures usage differently, by tasks, operations or executions, so the same workflow can cost very different amounts in each. The longer and more frequent your workflows, the more n8n's per-execution model tends to pull ahead. Work it out with your real volume and current prices.
Is n8n better than Zapier?
Sometimes yes, sometimes no. n8n gives more control over data, more flexibility with code and more configurable AI agents. Zapier is easier to learn and has more ready-made connectors. If your team is not technical and your workflows are short and simple, Zapier may well be the better choice for your company.
Make vs Zapier: which suits a non-technical small business?
Both work well without coding. Zapier is quicker to learn and suits linear workflows with well-known apps. Make takes a little more learning, but its visual canvas makes branching workflows and data transformations easier to follow. Try building the same simple workflow in both on their trial plans, and keep the one your team understands best.
Can I migrate workflows from Zapier or Make to n8n?
Yes, though there is usually no reliable automatic transfer. Each workflow is rebuilt in n8n from its logic, which is a good chance to review and document it. Start with the most expensive or critical workflows, run them side by side for a while and switch off the old ones only when the new ones work well.
What is the difference between n8n and Make?
Both let you draw workflows on screen and both support AI. Make runs in its vendor's cloud, bills by operations or credits and is easier to pick up for branching workflows. n8n can be installed on your own server, counts executions of a whole workflow and accepts code at any step, at the cost of a longer learning curve. Who will maintain the workflows usually tips the decision.
Which is best for GDPR compliance?
All three can be used in line with GDPR if they are configured properly and the relevant data processing agreements are in place. n8n adds the option of installing it on a server you control, which makes it easier to decide where data is stored. In every case, limit the data flowing through each workflow and review each provider's terms.